Where do ideas come from?
It's the age-old question people ask of the creative folk among them. Nobody has ever answered the question accurately, although many have answered it cleverly. Because nobody knows. Ideas, like life itself, come from nowhere and everywhere at once.
I've likened my own ability to come up with story ideas, gags, and so forth to a man standing up to his knees in a fully-stocked trout pond, chucking fish on shore as fast as he can. It's apt. I come up with several things a day, most days, which could be worked into entire projects. Just like fish, they can sometimes stink after a little time in the sun. But that's okay, because it would take me a decade to work through an average week's idea output, anyway.
This trout-scooping analogy isn't altogether charitable to myself.
It's nothing like that easy to come up with ideas. Not even if you find it easy, as I do. Because I've spent my entire life nurturing the ability to generate ideas, like working an obscure, hard-to-isolate muscle. My son can wiggle his ears, for example. I cannot. My ears seem to me to be anchored directly to the layer of fat that surrounds my brain; they do not wiggle. But there are muscles there, and my son has figured out how to make them work. I'd prefer he exercised his
writing abilities in
English class, but we'll discuss that later, young man.
Likewise, I've spent my entire conscious life coming up with ideas, finding them in the shadows and valleys of the world around me. It's a skill I have worked at, hard, for decades. The reason it seems easy to me now is because my story-idea muscles are hypertrophic to the point that they don't fit into a regular shirt.
Is coming up with ideas like wiggling your ears or lifting weights? Of course not. This is why it's so hard to explain. In one sense, ideas are just
there. When you hit on a really good idea, it feels inevitable. It seems like somebody else must already have discovered and exploited it. As it happens, sometimes this is true. But that underlines the point. Ideas seem to exist outside us, something we discover in the aether. That's part of the ability I've been developing all these years: to
see an idea, no matter how well-camouflaged or faint it is, against the disruptive background of existence, and to capture it quickly before it fades into obscurity once more.
This makes ideas sound rather like something from H.P. Lovecraft.
But it's true. We catch ideas by the tail, most of the time, and it is a frantic effort to secure our grip while pursuing the things through the canebrake. As often as not, we wind up face-down in the mud with a handful of loose hair, the idea frisking away through the glades to be caught by somebody else. I keep the tail-hairs as trophies, myself. However, there's more to it.
Ideas don't have any life of their own, not really. Nor do they exist outside our minds until we discover them, floating in the wind. They come from inside us, amalgamated from our experiences, opinions, fears and appetites. They come from what interests us, and what we think might interest other people; what we believe, what we wish, what we hope. In this way, ideas are grown, after a fashion, like cabbages. There's a seed, and it blossoms into something, or it withers. Or a rabbit eats it.
My father, who was a children's book author and artist, was often asked about where his ideas came from. He would always answer in exactly the same way, very gravely:
Every Thursday night, I go into downtown Peterborough [New Hampshire]. There's a lamp post there. I stand under it for a couple of hours, and then a little green man walks by. He gives me my ideas. Then he leaves, and I go home and work on them.
I've just figured out how to be my own little green man.