I've been trying to shorten up novel #2,
The Ormolu Clock. Usually I can hack a lot of material out of a project -- it's a habit from my screenwriting days, when there was a 105-page limit beyond which only cruel sorrow awaited. You cut anything and everything to get it to length.
Novels don't have to be any particular length, but this one was too long. It meandered around. I was basing it on a kind of Dickensian structure, that episodic approach which allows for a great deal of texture and detail with big scene changes. But it was too rambling, too indulgent.
So I started cutting. I figured I could easily remove 15,000 words.
I was only able to cut 5,000 words so far, and ultimately that might be it. Here's why. The problem wasn't so much the length of the telling, but the duration of events in the story. I wrote one series of events that takes place over three days; rewriting it to take
one day made all the difference, even though it didn't shorten the text very much. I had another passage that took four days. Rewrote it to take place in a single night. It got maybe 500 words shorter, but now it seems far more purposeful and dramatic.
So sometimes, it appears, you can shorten events in a story and get the same effect as shortening the story itself.
Of course, I could be wrong. It might still be 10,000 words too long.